The women of Sierra Leone bear the brunt of empty promises CO2 trade
Mariatu Sesay (45) was not allowed to talk about the project. (Photo Abdul Hamid Kanu)Trouw | 19 April 2026

The women of Sierra Leone bear the brunt of empty promises CO2 trade

In the West African Sierra Leone, a large reforestation project began in 2021 that would have to store millions of tonnes of CO2. But the inhabitants whose country is do not always know what they are signing for. “They made a lot of promises that they didn’t keep.”

by Mella Fuchs

(Note this article was translated from Dutch to English by Google Translate)

The sandy road to the villages in Sierra Leone's Port Loko district is full of large, deep puddles, which motorcyclists zigzaggingly dodge. This is the birthplace of Bai Bureh, the leader of the Temne people who unleashed a revolt against British rule and a newly introduced tax in 1898. His men held out for months against the much better-armed British troops, which yields respect to Bureh to this day.

This is also the ground for a large-scale carbon credit project that began here in 2021. On paper, it sounds like a solution to the climate problem: planting trees on 25,000 hectares (about the municipality of Amsterdam), which can store twelve million tonnes of CO2 in fifty years. The carbon credits are sold, and for the population it offers opportunities for development.

But the Swiss NGO Heks, together with the local civil society organization Silnorf (Sierra Leone Network on the Right to Food), discovered that the companies involved did not comply with Sierra Leone's progressive land law. Women, in particular, bear the brunt of that.

For it is they who used this land for the household. The Sierra Leonean company that runs the project, Rewilding Maforki, describes the area as ‘low-intensive and unproductive’, but residents told that they grew cassava, groundnuts, peppers and cucumbers there. “Before Rewilding came, people farmed on that land,” says Dorah Bangura (20), a resident of the village of Manbureh. “Men are usually the owners of the farms, but the land is only used by the women.”

Yet women were hardly involved in the negotiations on the project, according to research by Heks and Silnorf. They were regularly not invited, and otherwise they could only listen and were not asked for their opinion.

This applies, for example, to Mariatu Sesay (45) from the village of Roktolon, which sits in yellow-orange wax print under a leafy tree on a bench, together with other inhabitants from the village. She attended four meetings about the project. “As a woman, I was not allowed to talk. The leaders of the community are the ones who do the talking. There was nothing I wanted to add.”

Life of self-sufficient agriculture

The reforestation project focuses on sixty small villages with usually about fifty to three hundred inhabitants, who live largely on self-sufficient agriculture. Canadian carbon trader Carbon Done Right (formerly Climate X) is regulating the investments. The Swiss consultancy Ecosecurities supports in the registration and necessary certification.

There is also a big name from the fossil fuel industry involved: BP Carbon Trading Limited. This subsidiary of the British oil company BP concluded a financing agreement of 2.5 million dollars (about 2.1 million euros). It got exclusivity on the first carbon credits that would be generated on 5000 hectares.

On the way to the villages involved, human rights activist Ali Haj Bunduka points from Silnorf to the surrounding area. To the right of the road are dense tropical forests. On the left are fairly empty fields with small trees here and there. It's the fields of Rewilding Maforki, he says.

According to project documents, it concerns ‘degraded’ or ‘unproductive’ land, parts of which were previously used for palm oil plantations. In 2009 Sierra Leone Agriculture Ltd. – led by the current CEO of Carbon Done Right – took possession of land here and built plantations. But within a few years, the company stopped its operations.

Members of the local communities then went to court to reclaim their land. They would not have been sufficiently informed about the project at the time. In 2018, Sierra Leone's high court ruled in favour of them: the country had to be returned and the company had to pay the villagers about 250,000 dollars in lease. That amount has not been paid so far.

The country became popular again

When the palm oil plantations disappeared, communities began to use parts of the land again for their own purposes. Not always permanent, but as a spare land or for seasonal crops.

A few years later, the country proved to be in demand again, this time at Rewilding Maforki, whose co-founder and majority shareholder is the current CEO of Carbon Done Right, who was therefore previously involved in the palm oil plantations.

The irony does not escape Silva Lieberherr of the Swiss NGO Heks. “This project is being put down as: that land of former plantations has been relegated, we are coming to save it. But it’s partly the same people who started the plantations and screwed up.”

The laws have changed in the meantime. In 2022 Sierra Leone stipulates that the rental or sale of family land must be ‘free, prior and informed consent’. At least 60 percent of the adult members of a land-owning family – men and women – must agree in writing. The responsibility to comply with this lies with the investor.

But the reforestation project started before even one document was signed, according to field research by Heks and Silnorf. The first agreements were signed in September and October 2023, when Carbon Done Right already spoke of a rounded second planting season.

Because the trees were already being planted, members of the community asked for compensation for their land. In the end, a lease was set of 14 dollars per hectare per year, while the companies predicted a profit of 360 dollars per hectare per year.

The residents didn't know what they were signing for

Some families were paid that money, too. But at the same meetings, they were presented with documents to sign. Many residents told Heks that those procedures were in a hurry and that they did not know what exactly they were drawing. The documents were drawn up in English, a language that is hardly spoken in this area. They did not receive copies of the contracts.

Some understood that it was a lease agreement, but had little knowledge of the precise conditions. Others thought they were simply signing a receipt for the money.

When Heks asked the Rewilding Maforki for proof that the other family members were well informed and had given permission, the company could not show that.

In the village of Roktolon also lives Fatmata Turay (60). She inherited land from her parents, which she manages together with her brothers. They didn't rent everything to Rewilding Maforki: one part they keep to themselves.

Turay heard about the project through her brother, who is deputy village chief. “We were told they were going to use trees to build furniture from,” she says. Her brother, who wants to be in the conversation with the journalist of Trouw, shakes his head and says that she does know that it has to do with carbon.

When asked if women have been consulted and asked for permission, Turay says she doesn't know that, because she wasn't there. But she knows that women are generally not consulted. It would be better if that happened, she says. “First of all, they are people. If they are landowners, they should be involved in discussions about the land. Then they have the chance to express their concerns. You can't have a conversation about someone's possession without that person being present. Women tend to find solutions.”

Like Turay, Bangura knows little about the project that is close to her village. “I know they’re planting trees,” she said. “But I don’t really know the purpose. All I know is that they ask us to protect the trees and not create wildfires.”

She was at a few meetings, but had little influence there, she says. “Only the elderly can decide. So even when we're there, our votes are not counted. I can't tell you anything about land. The elderly do not involve us.”

The research by Heks and Silnorf shows that many people in the communities do not know what carbon credits are. There is also uncertainty about the duration of the project. Trees do not store a lot of CO2 until they are large. If they burn or are cut down, it is largely released. Therefore, companies must ensure that the forest will continue to exist for a long time. In project documentation of Rewilding Maforki it says that this project covers fifty years.

But many residents say they never heard that. Some speak in twenty to thirty years. Many interviewees say they never gave permission for fifty years – and wouldn’t. “Generations that have yet to be born will blame us if we don’t protect this land,” a Landowner told Heks researchers.

According to Lieberherr of NGO Heks, that confusion shows that the procedures have not been followed correctly. "People are confused," she says. “They do not have a document that has been explained to them and that they have deliberately signed. This is exactly what the law requires.”

The company promised development to the communities involved: schools, hospitals, wells and scholarships. The law requires such benefits to be recorded in writing. Oral promises are not enough, especially when it comes to decades of land use.
Many promises remained

In some villages, wells have indeed been built and pupils were given school material. But many other promises remained. “The only thing that has changed in our community is the well,” says Bangura. She works, like most here, on the land. It's a few miles away, and she walks there every day. There they grow rice and cassava. She was in school until she got pregnant. Her child is now two years old. Next year, she wants to register for her exams. “But they made a lot of promises that they didn’t keep. Like the construction of a hospital.”

Employment was another promise. Rewilding Maforki said he employed fifty permanent employees in early 2024 and has more than two hundred people on the payroll every month. In fact, project documents state that three hundred people from the community would have been hired as permanent employees. However, interviewees say that it is almost always about temporary contracts: fire prevention, planting trees, pruning shrubs.

“Local people have been hired,” says Lieberherr, “but it concerns temporary contracts. It is less than expected and also substandard about what the community itself could have done with that country.”

Trouw repeatedly asked Rewilding Maforki and BP for a response to the findings, but received no response.

Many trees are in poor condition

At the end of 2023, two years since the start of the project, only 1400 hectares had been planted. The project is now at a standstill. The tree nursery is abandoned; plastic bags and jars are scattered around the grounds.

Of the trees that have already been planted, many are in poor condition. Some are already dead, some of them are burned. Sometimes only one tree species is planted. Residents say the planting moment was poorly chosen: at the end of the rainy season.

BP has not renewed the contract with Rewilding Maforki, and so new investors are being sought. “Rewilding blames us,” says Lieberherr. “But I think it’s more likely that BP has changed strategy because of the overall turn in world politics. That greenwashing is no longer so necessary.”

There are only a few people employed to keep up with the forest and make sure that the trees are not overgrown. Alhaji Amadu Bunduka of Silnorf says the rent has to be paid every October, but that that has not happened. The communities of Kasseh and Bureh have not been paid for a year now, that of Maconteh two years.

“I don’t think we’ve been treated fairly,” Bangura says at the end of the conversation. “But now there are organizations that tell us what rights we have. We know there's a new law. So in the future, we’re going to make sure we get involved.”
URL to Article
https://farmlandgrab.org/post/33612
Source
Trouw https://www.trouw.nl/buitenland/de-vrouwen-van-sierra-leone-zijn-de-dupe-van-loze-beloftes-co-handel~be8616ae/?referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2F