Exemption of Environmental Impact Assessment for Demerara Distillers Limited’s Farm has failed to ensure citizen rights, environmental protections and statutory rights
The DDL dairy farmStabroek News | 19 February 2026

Exemption of Environmental Impact Assessment for Demerara Distillers Limited’s Farm has failed to ensure citizen rights, environmental protections and statutory rights
     
On October 30, 2025, two DDL shareholders, Danuta Radzik and Vanda Radzik, the Greenheart Movement and other members of Guyanese civil society submitted the following objections to Demerara Distillers Limited’s (DDL’s) Dairy Farm project to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). On December 13, 2025, after repeated phone calls and no acknowledgement of our submission, we were informed that a public notice was placed on May 18, 2025, in the Sunday Chronicle, exempting the project from an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), and noting that objections had to be made within 30 days. We are sharing our written objections as we firmly believe that the process for Guyanese citizens, communities and stakeholders to hold companies, whether local or global, accountable for environmental issues are inadequate. It is clear that this process remains heavily skewed towards those with power, access, influence and wealth. 

The EPA Act, Constitutional Rights and Treaty Violations

The DDL dairy project raises serious concerns about the EPA’s practice of exempting major developments from environmental impact assessments (EIAs). EIAs are intended to ensure transparency: they document environmental and public health risks, allow scrutiny, and invite informed objections. Unilateral exemptions undermine that process and effectively sidestep public accountability.

The Environmental Protection Act (EP Act) requires that notices explaining such exemptions be published in at least one newspaper. In practice, the EPA interprets this requirement narrowly, issuing a single notice in the Sunday Chronicle and allowing minimal time of 30 days for stakeholders to respond.

Despite the EP Act’s clear prohibition against project work proceeding before appeals are resolved, when the EPA’s public notice of EIA exemption was published on May 18, 2025, media reports reveal that land clearing, well digging, and significant construction activity, including road upgrades and bridge works, were already underway at the DDL dairy site as early as January 2024. By January 2025, over sixty workers from Guyana, Venezuela, and Cuba were accommodated at the facility, supporting a $20 million expansion. All of this was a year and a half before the public notice appeared in the Chronicle.

These actions are not procedural trivialities. The EPA bears a constitutional responsibility to safeguard the country’s environmental rights, including access to information, public participation, and environmental justice. Those duties are reinforced by domestic law and by treaties such as Escazú, which emphasize transparency and citizen involvement in environmental decision-making. Moreover, the EP Act specifically identifies animal husbandry in sensitive ecological areas as an activity requiring EIAs, a safeguard rooted in the Aarhus Convention and the Convention on Biological Diversity.

When consultation, transparency, and oversight are diluted, it is not only environmental standards that suffer; it is the public’s right to informed participation in decisions that affect their land, water, and future.

Environmental Risks from Aquifer Contamination

The proposed DDL Dairy Farm Project, located at Moblissa, risks contaminating underground aquifers through runoff from animal waste, effluents, and chemicals used in operations. Moblissa’s white sand soils contain little silt or clay, resulting in fast drainage and poor nutrient retention. In the absence of a confining clay layer to protect underlying aquifers, these soils act like a sieve, meaning that anything applied to surface soils will/can leach rapidly into groundwater. According to Guyana Water Inc (GWI), aquifers in Essequibo, Demerara and Berbice Regions provide more than 95% of domestic potable water. These aquifers are particularly shallow and permeable in the Moblissa area where DDL’s Farm Project is located. Industrial dairy farms are known to be major sources of nitrates, ammonia, phosphorus and E coli because of manure runoff, silage and leaching of fertilizer from fodder crop fields. As such, nitrate and phosphate pollution from manure and fertilizers at DDL’s Dairy Farm could enter drinking water sources, creating health risks for rural communities using well water.

Dairy farming also uses significant amounts of water.  According to the University of Kentucky, a dairy cow requires about 30 to 50 gallons of water per day, which can increase significantly with high milk production or heat stress. A cow producing a high volume of milk may need 150 – 200 litres of water in hot weather. Additionally, a further 100-200 litres could be needed for cleaning and milking operations which may result in overextraction of water resources. In the absence of an EIA, depletion or contamination of water sources for both agricultural purposes and human consumption could result in long-term water scarcity and affect food security, especially during dry seasons.

Manure treatment

The DDL Dairy Farm manure management plan appears incomplete and lacking in some key operational details. According to the project summary, 60 percent of manure will be collected while cows are feeding. However, it does not explain what happens to manure produced throughout the remainder of the day, nor does it address how methane emissions from rumen fermentation will be managed.

The documentation also provides no information on the size, construction, or containment features of the proposed manure ditch and manure pit. If these structures are soil-based leaching into groundwater aquifers is a realistic possibility. Moreover, the project summary reflects a limited waste management and biosecurity plan, with no clear protocols for handling manure, animal pharmaceuticals, or disease control.

Information is also limited on the planned 42 x 31 x 4.5m manure lagoon, scheduled to receive 40,000 litres of liquid manure and effluents daily.  The summary does not specify the oxidation process to be used, nor whether manure repurposed as bedding will undergo the expected 100-day treatment cycle. It further states that approximately 30 percent of manure will be left in the bedding area for “semi-composting,” aided by a “designated cultivator” and shed ventilation. However, no information is provided on what a designated cultivator entails or how such ventilation would mitigate methane emissions.

Experts emphasize that a comprehensive waste management strategy is essential, as contamination from nitrates and E. coli in water supplies is associated with gastrointestinal and thyroid cancers in adults, and can cause dysentery, kidney failure, and even death among vulnerable populations.

Risks from GMOs and Non-native Grass Species

The introduction of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) and/or non-native grass species could result in disruption of local ecosystems, cross-contamination with local flora
 and long-term ecological effects which could be irreversible. Guyana’s National Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan 2012-2020 promotes the prevention of ecological degradation from invasive species and the preservation of native species and biodiversity. Unfortunately, DDL’s Farm Project disregards these risks by planning the introduction of imported, non-indigenous dairy cows, which may be unsuitable to Guyana’s climate and conditions and GMO-enhanced grass species, possibly incompatible with native grass species.

Four types of grasses will be used to feed the cows: Mombasa Guinea Grass, Forage Maize (corn), Tropical Lucerne and Cow Pea. Here are some of the problems associated with these grasses: Mombasa grass needs high levels of nitrogen for optimal growth. This can be expensive, environmentally problematic and invasive, out competing native vegetation and requiring well drained soils with good fertility, not found in sandy soils at Moblissa. Forage maize can have several negative environmental and nutritional impacts. These include soil degradation, potential for mycotoxin contamination, and greenhouse gas emissions. Tropical Lucerne can present challenges such as increased diseases and potential for crown rot due to high humidity.

Greenhouse Gas Emissions

It is well known that a single cow, including a penned cow, produces about 250 – 500 liters (154 to 264 pounds) of methane per day. This amount varies significantly based on factors like the cow’s size, diet type, feed quality, quantity, and breed. This methane is primarily released through burping and flatulence as a natural byproduct of rumen fermentation. Factors influencing methane production include diet; high-forage diets produce more methane while quality and quantity of feed, animal size and breed, larger animals and specific breeds, like Holsteins cows, produce more methane. The DDL Farm Project Summary fails to identify the breed of cows they intend to import. Regardless of breed of cow, the DDL Dairy Farm will be a significant source of methane, nitrous oxide, and carbon dioxide emissions. Based on a total of 900 cows, total project emissions will be equal to approximately 4,230 metric tonnes of CO2 emissions a year- the equivalent of the annual emissions of 919 passenger vehicles, or the carbon footprint of over 300 average Guyanese households. Based on a total of 900 cows, between 91,250 and 182,500 litres of methane will be emitted annually from DDL’s Dairy Farm. Additionally, a smaller amount of methane is released from excreted feces and manure decomposition. Methane is known to be a potent greenhouse gas, with a warming potential of 25 to 30 times greater than carbon dioxide over a 100-year period. This project will also increase the output of other harmful greenhouse gases such as Nitrous Oxide (from manure and fertilizer use), and Carbon Dioxide (from machinery use and land use to cultivate animal feed).

Environmental Failures of Similar Dairy Projects

Environmental risks of dairy project like DDL’s Dairy Project include New Zealand Waikato Mega-Dairy Expansion (2016-2022) which resulted in groundwater contamination and soil degradation. India’s Punjab Dairy Intensification (2015-2020) resulted in aquifer depletion, pathogen rich run off entering rivers leading to fish kills, waste mismanagement leading to seepage into groundwater and dairies shut down by lawsuits. In Arava Dairy Project Southern Israel (2009-2014), heat stress led to decreased milk yields, cow mortality, soil salinization, disruption of flora and fauna and abandonment after 5 years due to underperformance and high operational costs.

The LR Israeli Group, which is in partnership with DDL Dairy Project, has a track record of environmental failures and controversy in dairy/agro-industrial projects: In Angola agricultural development failed after aquifer overuse and fertilizer mismanagement. In Papua New Guinea the agro-industrial project had to be withdrawn due to social conflict and water pollution. In Ghana the dairy project was suspended after underperformance and financial mismanagement. The lack of due diligence in partnership with LR Group raises serious questions about the sustainability of DDL’s Dairy Project.

Lack of Stakeholder Consultation

The DDL Dairy Farm Project Summary failed to identify stakeholder consultations with communities/residents in the Moblissa area, Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC) for Indigenous populations potentially affected, or consultations with key institutions, civil society or environmental groups violating national and international norms.

Given the significant environmental risks, the decision to exempt the DDL Dairy Project from an Environmental Impact Assessment is both surprising and concerning. Guyana’s Environmental Protection Act clearly requires EIAs for large-scale farming and agro-processing operations. The project includes 250 hectares, or 617 acres, dedicated to field crops alone, excluding additional land for housing more than 900 cows, veterinary facilities, milking parlours, hay barns, and fourteen other planned structures. By any reasonable standard in Guyana, this qualifies as a large-scale development. The EPA should reconsider its decision and require a full Environmental Impact Assessment before granting any environmental permit for the project.
URL to Article
https://farmlandgrab.org/post/33613
Source
Stabroek News https://www.stabroeknews.com/2026/02/19/features/in-the-diaspora/exemption-of-environmental-impact-assessment-for-demerara-distillers-limiteds-farm-has-failed-to-ensure-citizen-rights-environmental-protections-and-statutory-rights/