Family orchards are forced to sell in Central WA in latest land grab
Mike Clayton inspects a bin full of sweetheart cherries. The Claytons are one of many farming families who have seen thousands of acres of Washington’s fertile land along with water rights scooped up by investment firms and private holding companies.  (Nick Wagner / The Seattle Times)      Seattle Times | 8 August 2026

Family orchards are forced to sell in Central WA in latest land grab    

By David Guterson

I FIRST LEARNED about April Clayton in the early summer of 2025 from the president of the Washington State Tree Fruit Association. I’d written to him to say I hoped to speak with an orchardist who’d recently gone broke — having heard, I added, that a lot of them had. “April Clayton,” he wrote back, “had to lease out her orchards last year. April would be a good one for you to meet.”

I went online and listened to her on a podcast called “Real Food, Real People.” “I kind of resisted getting into farming at first,” she said, “because I didn’t want to be known as Mike’s wife. I’d just finished my Ph.D. I didn’t want to be, Oh, the farmer … Oh, you know, his wife.”

I called her. She was driving, on speaker phone. She drove endlessly, she told me. From her house it was 40 minutes to Wenatchee, where she almost always went for groceries. Right now, as we spoke, her daughter, Jojo, was at a theater day camp even further away, in Leavenworth. If she took Jojo to camp, then stopped for groceries, then went home, that meant 2½ hours of driving. Picking up Jojo at the end of the day meant another 2½ hours.

She was in Wenatchee a lot these days, she said, because since they’d lost the farm she’d taken a job teaching chemistry at Wenatchee Valley College.

Jojo, 13, loved performing in musical productions, and was in a troupe called StageKids. John, on the other hand — April’s 15-year-old son — was a relative homebody. What John liked to do was operate heavy equipment on the farm and play video games in the basement. As for Mike — April’s husband — he still did what he’d done before they’d leased away the farm: plant, irrigate, prune, thin, harvest, and manage apple and cherry orchards. He was supposed to be getting a salary for that, and April and Mike were supposed to be getting $1,450 annually for each acre they leased out, too, but so far, in year two of their lease, they’d hardly been paid.

The guy they were leasing to, April explained, had gotten overextended and, just like them, was biting the dust.

* * *

Say you’re an orchardist with a few acres of apples who contracts with a packer to ship your fruit to retailers. The contract ensures that when you deliver your apples, the packer will pay you for them. That said, the price you get for a bin of apples might be less than you paid to fill it. You don’t get to say, “My bins of apples are $100 each this year.” The packer, instead, names the price per bin.

Something else: If all you do is grow apples, the price you get for them will determine your financial fate, but if growing apples is only one aspect of your business, meaningful advantages will accrue to you. If, on top of growing apples, you buy them from other growers, sort and pack both yours and theirs, and market and ship both yours and theirs, you can take a loss on growing apples and make it up elsewhere. You can also lowball growers you buy apples from, and keep doing that until they are losing so much money they are all but forced to sell their orchards to you.

Buying up orchards and vertically integrating has obvious benefits. If you grow, pack and ship a hundred million apples and make a penny on each, you’ll make a million dollars, but if all you do is grow a million apples — paying, along the way, everything it costs to bring them to maturity and get them off your trees — you’ll be lucky to make $5,000.

Under the unrelenting summer sun, a cherry picker carries a ladder to a block of sweetheart cherry trees near Orondo, Douglas County. (Nick Wagner / The Seattle Times)

Even doing volume business as vertically integrated enterprises, though, Washington’s mega-fruit companies are small in the scheme of things. That’s because far-flung investment firms, taking note of conditions that make owning Washington orchards a good idea, are swallowing them up, as in a food chain.

It’s fine with investment firms if, for a long time, they make little, or even take a loss, in the fruit world. Eventually the land underneath their fruit will be worth a lot more than they paid for it, and the water rights associated with it will gain value, too. Equally promising, Washington’s fruit country is a northward play, meaning climate change factors positively in their analyses. Forecasts call for today’s two largest fruit-growing states, California and Florida, to increasingly contend with water shortages and with the escalating costs of rising heat, while Washington, with its abundant water and geographical advantage, pays off handsomely in the new climate dispensation.

In 1999, I wrote for Harper’s on the Washington State apple industry, structuring my essay around visits to growers. Since then, Grady Auvil’s orchards and packing shed have been subsumed by Fiera Comox, a Montreal investment firm with $4.5 billion in assets under its management, and Ralph Broetje’s orchards were bought by the Ontario Teacher’s Pension Fund, which has $269 billion. Wawona Packing is now owned by Paine Schwartz, FruitSmart by the Universal Corporation, Pride Packing by Vanguard International, Holtzinger Fruit by Intracorp Capital, and Taggares Fruit by the Harvard Endowment. Private equity and institutional investment have come to dominate Washington’s orchard country.

* * *

I went to visit the Claytons. They lived on a hill east of the Columbia River. Their house was tucked into a lee between benches. In all directions, fruit grew beneath a hot sun. It was late July, the end of cherry-picking season. Most of the cherries were off the trees, but young apples still grew in profusion. An arid stillness had a grip on things. A lull between harvests had just begun. It was a good time to talk, or might have been in different circumstances. So much had gone wrong they didn’t know where to start.

We sat in their kitchen. Through the window above their sink, more than a thousand acres of fruit stretched downhill. To the northwest, April said, a huge swath of orchards was owned by a literal billionaire whose primary business was land investment. To the southwest, Fiera Comox — the institutional investor in Montreal with a $4.5 billion portfolio — was in charge. In between them, to the west, an enormous tract was owned by a firm in Boston called Agis Capital that had invested more than a billion dollars in U.S. farmland.

April, who until recently had presided over the Chelan/Douglas County Farm Board, said that orchard acquisition by large-scale private equity and institutional investors was less about fruit than it was about land. It was land they wanted — land and the water associated with it.

Land and water, earth’s fundamentals. If you fear the day might come when contemporary forms of wealth, security and advantage collapse, and you have the wherewithal to prepare for it, you might — depending on your view — invest in land and water. And while you’re at it, why not invest in both for their current merits, since, on the way to a dystopia that might never come, returns should be competitive? (One widely used benchmark, the NCREIF Farmland Index, pegs returns today at just under 10% annually.)

For decades, April said, she and Mike had started each year by taking a half million-dollar farm production loan. That’s what it takes, she explained, to week by week and month by month pay whatever has to be paid to keep their orchard going. There had been years when they’d made money and years when they hadn’t. Cherries paid in October, apples in March, so annually there were long periods of worry before checks arrived, and many years dismayed shock when they did. It was their way of life to be apprehensively in debt, but now and then a good year would come along, so on they’d gone until they couldn’t anymore.

In 2017, April said, they lost a lot of money. The primary reason was that, by then, investment firms had elbowed their way into the organic apple market so aggressively — the Claytons had long been organic growers — that the price collapsed. In the past, a packer might have paid the Claytons $600 a bin for organic Honeycrisps, but now that much bigger orchards were growing them in huge numbers, supply had outstripped demand so severely that, if the Claytons paid people to pick their Honeycrisps, the cost of getting those Honeycrisps to their packer would exceed what the packer would pay for them. The only thing left to do, then, was watch them fall from the trees and rot on the ground.

Mike and April hobbled along in the usual fretful manner until 2021, when, as often happens, the weather didn’t cooperate and crop revenue dived. “You’d think that’d make it a bad year for us,” April said. Fortunately, though, they had shelled out for crop insurance, so in 2021, they garnered a net profit.

By 2023, the Claytons, for the first time in decades, had money in the bank, which they used to get out of debt and to self-finance. This act of faith turned out to be ill-timed, because 2023 was a bad year for the usual reasons — weather, price crash, inflation, expenses — and in the end they lost about $650,000.

They gave up at that point, but, since they couldn’t bring themselves to sell, leased instead. For now.

The two of them had a plan for that — or at least a dream about it. Their son John, a 10th grader, was a natural on heavy equipment. Maybe when he graduated from high school in three years, they’d go into the heavy equipment business together. They’d excavate and grade for people building houses along the river and in the winery country on the far side of it. The region, April said, was in the midst of a post-COVID real estate boom.

A few weeks later, I found an article in the Investor’s Business Daily titled “Microsoft Goes Long in Farmland: Could This Investing Sector Exceed The $3.8 Trillion Commercial Office Market?”(Bill Gates, apparently, is the largest holder of farmland in the United States.) “For wealthy individuals and families,” it said, “the desire to diversify investments to avoid ‘concentration risk’ rises as investable assets go up.”

I didn’t ask the Claytons about their politics or who they vote for, but I will suggest that, when you hear people say they feel betrayed by Wall Street, or when they decry or bemoan elites, the outlines of their lives might look something like this.

* * *

Food and agriculture expert Sarah Mock, writing in The Counter (now Grist), recounted how, having grown up on a small family farm, she’d long seen them as virtuous. “Small” had meant to her honest reward for honest labor; “family” had meant there was more to life than profit. “Small” and “family” were antidotes to “corporate” and “industrial” — to all those “evils of commerce that in our guts we believe should be kept far away.”

The more deeply Mock interrogated these assumptions, though, the harder it was for her to maintain them. Though “loath to rob her past of its agrarian halo,” she nevertheless grew to see family farms as stolen land, and small family farmers as propped up by “tens of billions of dollars in direct government purchases, payments, and subsidized crop insurance, in addition to massive tax breaks.”

Mock, whose body of work includes two books — “Farm (and Other F Words): The Rise and Fall of the Small Family Farm” and “Big Team Farms: Growing Farms Differently” — is far from alone in holding this view of things. Adam Calo, an assistant professor of environmental governance and politics at Radboud University in the Netherlands, has challenged in his work the sanctity of a land-use vision based on “individual land ownership, single proprietor farming, neoliberal logics of change, and whiteness.” Gabriel N. Rosenberg, Associate Professor of Gender, Sexuality, Feminist Studies and History at Duke, has written that “farmers have always been at the cutting edge of North American territorial and ecological colonization,” and that rural life in the United States “enjoys exceptional deference and celebration, fetishization even.” Robin Rotman and Sophie Mendelson — the former an associate professor of energy and environmental law and policy at the University of Missouri, the latter an alum of the Yale Sustainable Food Program — have argued that the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s definition of “family farm” has “unfairly aggregated advantages for the benefit of a particular kind of family (nuclear) and farmer (white, male, and straight).”

The gist here is at odds with a mainstay posture of old-school progressivism: namely, that family farms should be protected and preserved as a bulwark against a future in which the American food system is in the hands of Wall Street. It calls, instead, for letting them wither, and starting over with a new paradigm.

* * *

The enormous swath of orchards west of the Claytons’ house is, financially speaking, cryptic. It puts me in mind of a San Francisco Chronicle opinion article written by Calo after he’d combed through thousands of parcel records in an attempt to figure out who controls California’s farms. “Today,” he concluded, “ownership of the land that feeds us is increasingly hidden behind layers of shell companies and trusts, making it nearly impossible to know who controls these resources.” Flying under the radar, Calo wrote, farmland investment acquisitions are covertly transforming agricultural lands from “a distributed public good under community-based stewardship” to financial holdings.

Shell companies and trusts predominate near the Claytons, too. There, almost 50 squares of 10 or so acres each are owned by an entity called Red Stick Farms Washington, whose mailing address is a post office box in Turlock, Calif. Six more of the same size are owned by Pamunkey Washington, also with a post office box in Turlock. North of both are seven tracts of varying sizes and configurations owned by the Four Corners Farmland Fund Douglas, which has a Boston mailing address. The Four Corners Fund has orchards comprising about 500 acres; together with the Red Stick and Pamunkey holdings, it’s part of an approximately 1,000 acre tract of land owned, ultimately, by Agis Capital in Boston, which has a satellite office in Turlock.

The largest Agis holding in this vicinity comprises 265 acres, valued in 2022 at over $4.3 million; today it is worth more than $6 million, a number that combines the value of land, improvements to it — say upgraded irrigation or more productive trellis systems — and the value of the fruit produced there. In that four-year period, the value of the fruit produced on those 264 acres actually decreased, while the value of the land and its improvements rose dramatically. In other words, fruit was an afterthought for Agis Capital. What mattered was land and its associated water rights.

There’s something impersonal and inert about mega-orchards. You can drive long distances astride them on dirt roads and not see a soul. Their perfectly calibrated irrigation systems turn on and off automatically. The trellises and spindles on which their fruit is grown are rigorously uniform in height and spacing. Fecund as these orchards are, they lack the raw and wild feel of life. A hollow silence pervades their endless rows.

* * *

The Wanapum people once lived in large numbers downriver from the Claytons, and a much smaller number still live there today. “Wanapum” and “wampum” lend themselves to conflation. “Wampum” are the shell beads of Eastern Woodland tribes; “Wanapum” are people who live, now, near Mattawa, Grant County, in Central Washington. “Wana” means river; “pum” means people. The word pum derives from the beating of a human heart — pum, pum, pum, pum. Humans as the beating heart of a place.

Wanapum tribal member Clayton Buck (that his first name is the same as Mike and April’s surname is a coincidence) shared with me his people’s history while we sat in the Wanapum Heritage Center on the east bank of the Columbia near Priest Rapids Dam. I had sought Buck out after pondering the center’s exhibits and artifacts, and he had kindly agreed to meet. Clayton’s father, grandfather and great-grandfather had led the band before him; now here he was, a direct and quiet man in his late 40s, steadfastly dedicated to the well-being of his people.

Buck told me that the precontact territory of the Wanapum is hard to pin down. There’s a stretch of the Columbia they long considered theirs, he said, but as they traveled away from it in any direction, their sense of a just claim became less certain, and beyond there they knew they had none.

The heritage center we were sitting in was on the site of what was once the Wanapum winter village of P’na. The manner of Buck’s people in winter was to draw together in places like P’na where there was no uncertainty as to their right to be there, and where there were practical advantages for thriving through the cold season. When spring came, they traveled in large numbers over the course of days to camas-root fields near what is now Soap Lake. In summer, they crossed into ambiguously held territory expansive enough to mitigate against conflict, and there mostly hunted. In fall they moved into huckleberry fields, where they picked for weeks. Here, Buck explained, there was a navigating of sensitivities. The Wanapum had rights in that territory, incontestably, but the extent of those rights was in flux and debatable. 

As a rule, though, the Wanapum avoided conflict. The consensus among them was that confrontation was self-defeating. They viewed themselves as peaceful people. Their hope, always, was not to be attacked. The Wanapum, as a matter of principle, never went on the offensive, and fortunately for them there was sufficient sustenance available to allow for deference when needed.

Things went on like this for no one knows how long, said Buck, and then the Wanapum heard talk of new people. Soon some of them (Lewis, Clark and members of their expedition) were camped in Wanapum territory, and about 200 Wanapum went on horseback to see them in the spirit of curiosity and with hopes for barter. That was it for a while as far as interacting with the new people was concerned, but eventually more appeared and, without paying attention to the age-old sensitivities about who had rights on the land, stayed.

The Wanapum didn’t make a big deal about these newcomers, Buck told me. So what if a few of them wanted to build dwellings near the river, and grow plants, and pen in animals. It was clueless and an imposition, but on the other hand they weren’t interfering with the rhythm of things and didn’t dig roots or pick huckleberries much, or hunt or fish to excess, and so weren’t a threat to the thriving of Wanapum people, and anyway you could trade with them for the things they grew or for their tools, which were well-made. All in all, it was fine if they stayed — in fact, in some ways a plus. At first, Buck emphasized.

Later nearly everyone got sick, and a lot of people died, and the population necessary to the Wanapum economy dropped below a critical threshold, and after that, things fell apart so badly that the Wanapum almost ceased to exist.

Fortunately, though, for the Wanapum, the new people weren’t so enthusiastic about the territory as to usurp it in hordes, because to them it seemed barren, just a lot of arid steppe — meaning nothing could be grown there except close to the river. But then a wave of stockmen came and used the sagelands for grazing cattle and sheep, since in among the sage was bunchgrass suited to that purpose. With the disappearance of the bunchgrass the hunting got worse, Buck explained, so now there was that problem on top of all the others — dearth of food in general, sickness, high mortality, dysfunctional economy — and all of it taken together drove the Wanapum into the hands of the newcomers, who were not adverse to trading food for labor. 

Now that Buck’s people no longer moved about their long-standing territory in their long-standing way, the idea that it was legitimately theirs subsided, and besides, it had changed so much they couldn’t thrive there in the traditional manner anymore. What they needed under these new circumstances was to do some of the old things — gather roots and huckleberries, fish and hunt — but mainly, they needed to do farm work.

In the end, their sense of themselves as a people disintegrated. Many of those remaining left to do something else, and to be something other than Wanapum, but a few hung on because staying together and staying at home meant staying themselves. They didn’t want to become lost and be nobody or nothing — ghosts wandering in the world of the living.

By the early 1940s, the few remaining Wanapum were surviving on land no one else cared about. Whoever had come to own it by virtue of giving money to the U.S. government was so far away — like the U.S. government itself — that it made no difference to them, Buck said, if Wanapum people lived there. If a few last remnants of a disappearing people wanted to expire there, so what? What damage could they do to barren wastes?

Then that changed. Suddenly, barren wastes were in demand for a project the U.S. had in mind, which was to process uranium into plutonium for bombs. The government was sorry, its representatives told Buck’s people, but they had to leave. And so, in 1943, most of them moved upriver to what used to be P’na, their winter village.

They had a place again where they could continue in the face of things, but of course it felt constrained, especially when the Army fenced off 160,000 acres across the river from them to build an anti-aircraft artillery range. By 1951, the Army owned more than 250,000 acres there, including land where Wanapum were buried — which was, to the last of the living, as sad as all the rest of it and, in a gut-wrenching way, sadder, because even the dead now were hemmed in. Not only would the Wanapum soon cease to be, there would also be no memory of them.

P’na was on the Columbia at Priest Rapids, called that because traders met a Wanapum there whom they took to be a priest. As fate would have it, the site provoked a new problem for the remaining Wanapum in the early 1950s, when Priest Rapids was selected by the Army Corps of Engineers as the site for a new dam. The building of this dam, the Wanapum were told, would drown the place where P’na used to be, and where they now lived in last-gasp fashion, and again, representatives of the U.S. government were sorry about something that nevertheless had to be.

At that point there were four Wanapum families left. The Grant County Public Utility District, which owned and operated the dam, built houses for them to live in adjacent to it, and gave them jobs, too, promising that such perks would remain in place as long as there were Wanapum. And so it came to pass that, by 1961, the Priest Rapids Dam was to the north, the Hanford plutonium production plant to the south, the Army’s weapons testing range to the west, and private property to the east, and there they were, living in little houses inside a security fence constructed by the Grant County Public Utility District and maintaining the dam.

* * *

In 1961 — the year the Wanapum moved into those houses — Mike Clayton’s father, John Clayton Sr., was performing in air shows as part of the Air Force’s Thunderbird team, flying in aerobatic formations, rolling over, diving backward, and otherwise stunning watchers on the ground from the cockpit of an F-100C Super Sabre.

Clayton Sr., who’d grown up on a row-crop dirt farm in Texas, was stationed in a lot of places in the course of his Air Force career, including the air base at Laramie, Wyoming, where he went to see a promotional film produced by the Wenatchee Chamber of Commerce touting Washington State’s fruit growing country as full of potential for anyone intrepid enough to give orcharding a go. It was a promised land with all the right elements: long days of sun, ample water from a federally built irrigation system and the finest fruit-growing soil in the world. For eons, the pitch went, regular infusions of volcanic ash had ridden in on prevailing winds in the aftermath of Cascade Range eruptions, and now, in fruit country, the soil was six feet deep, all of it well-draining, gravel-free sandy loam.

Clayton Sr. went north and bought 29 acres for $11,000. By the mid-1980s, he and his wife Dottie had 80 acres of apples and cherries, and two sons working the place. On Sundays, they drove to an Episcopal church in Chelan, where Dottie played the organ and John was a warden. They died within a year of one another, when Mike Clayton was in his late 20s. In 1995, he and his brother inherited the family orchard.

On my last visit with the Claytons, I sat on the passenger side while April drove to Waterville, Douglas County, to pick up John Jr. and Jojo after school. They were both hungry, so we went to a place nearby that served burritos, where Jojo told me she could see living someday in Iceland or New Zealand, or maybe Switzerland or Australia. She wasn’t sure about college. Maybe, someday, she’d be an author or songwriter — something like that — or maybe join a circus. She wanted to live close to a city where there were a lot of things to do nearby. Right now she liked to read fantasy books and was rehearsing to play the part of Pumbaa the warthog in “The Lion King,” her second role with speaking lines and her first as a soloist. “I could be a singer some day,” she said. “I’d like to have a job in the creative industry that also pays well.”

The effusive Jojo is counterbalanced by her brother, who hardly speaks unless spoken to but is forthcoming and thoughtful when he does. He doesn’t want to go anywhere, he told me. He wants to stay in the house he’s always lived in, and — if he can — take over the farm some day. At 15, though, he sees the writing on the wall, and so, looking ahead, thinks the most likely scenario is that one day he’ll run heavy equipment for a living, or weld.

There are, today, 60 or so Wanapum. Like people everywhere, they’ve intermingled their way forward, and some of those who left the band have returned. They remain anomalous among the Indigenous peoples of North America in having never signed a treaty or moved to a reservation, which means they never traded or sold their land and remain its beating heart.
URL to Article
https://farmlandgrab.org/post/33626
Source
Seattle Times https://www.seattletimes.com/pacific-nw-magazine/family-orchards-are-forced-to-sell-in-central-wa-in-latest-land-grab/